In the 2007 Parents Involved decision, Chief Justice John Roberts shared a “simple and elegant logic” when he wrote, “The way to stop discrimination on the basis of race is to stop discriminating on the basis of race.”
A
recent Supreme Court decision ended discrimination on the basis of race in
college admissions. In writing about this topic, Mike Gonzalez discussed why
discrimination is not necessary.
The view that disparities, in educational
attainment and elsewhere, are prima facie evidence of something called “systemic
racism” – another ide virtually signaled without factual support – stands behind
this idea of getting a quick fix on results. It runs counter to the actual
data.
What
does the data say? According to Gonzalez, there are several “underserved” or “marginalized”
groups of Americans who do better than the average American.
·
52%
of U.S.-born Venezuelan Americans have at least graduated from a four-year
university, a much higher rate than the 23.5% of all Americans.
·
Other
“Latinos” … also have high levels of educational attainment.
·
73.5%
of U.S.-born Nigerian Americans are college graduates … compared to 32.9% of
U.S. whites.
·
Ghanaian
and West Indian Americans also do well across a number of indicators
The
question we should be asking is, why do some groups of Blacks or Hispanics do
better than other groups? Why do some minority groups become “very much
represented in colleges and universities” and achieve the American dream, while
other groups do not?
Gonzalez
shared an idea that may be helpful in bringing better understanding. He
suggested that the United States “needs to drop our current monolithic census
racial categories.” He used the term synthetic categories to describe “Hispanics”
and “Asian Americans” and said that those categories “throw off more heat than
light.”
Gonzalez
also indicated that lumping all Black Americans into one group is not helpful.
He said that there should be cross-referencing with the “nation of origin and
family intactness” to better “address the causes of the disparities.”
The
bottom line, according to Gonzalez, is to “go back to teaching the success
sequence” for school and life in general. The success sequence is to graduate
from high school, get a job, get married, have a baby – in that order – and to
stay married. The success sequence is a formula that can help Americans of all
races to become prosperous and happy.
No comments:
Post a Comment